Saturday, December 11, 2010

What's wrong with facing down furry critters?

Rex Murphy, National Post · Saturday, Dec. 11, 2010

It's been quite some time since Fess Parker -- coonskin cap on head and long rifle in hand -- half-sung, half-yodelled the great anthem of Davy Crockett, King of the Wild Frontier. Parker played the legendary frontiersman/congressman Crocket both on TV and in a feature film. He was also one of a number of singers who sent the song about Crockett onto the hit parade of the 1950s more than once.

No question it's a song about a hero. We're told right in the first stanza that he was "born on a mountaintop," which is a pretty special way of arriving in the world -- or, for that matter, Tennessee. But the real stamp indicating that he's a hero-to-be comes in the third line stating that "he killed himself a bear when he was only three." Being able to handle yourself in the woods and face down the furry critters that live there is something Americans (and Canadians) have long recognized as a mark of character and competence.

Speaking of which, Sarah Palin shot a caribou on the recent episode of her Discovery Channel travelogue, Sarah Palin's Alaska. Evidently the sight of the downing assaulted the brain and sensibilities of one of Hollywood's princes, Aaron Sorkin -- the man who perpetrated the seven soporific and suffocatingly earnest seasons of The West Wing. May I note that, outside a forced viewing of Oprah wailing to Barbara Walters, modern television has no greater torment than any episode of The West Wing. Keep in mind that I've seen episodes of Geraldo At Large, so I'm setting the bar quite high here.

Sorkin immediately lashed out on what has become the official complaints office of outraged progressives, the Huffington Post, berating Palin in terms that would be harsh if applied to the Ebola virus. He called her filming of the hunt a "snuff film"; lumped her in with Michael Vick, the felon dogfight empresario; more than implied she enjoyed "torturing" animals; and essentially put her down as "deranged" and "disgusting." He capped the whole thing off ever so graciously with a kind of warning to "Sarah Palin's Army of Arrogant A--holes," who are also, he tells us, a bunch of "macho Sh--heads."

The last shot of the abusive fusilade was an accusation that Palin had done something no one else had ever done. He charged: "That was the first moose ever murdered for political gain."

Where to begin, as they say. Well, first, it wasn't a moose. It was a caribou. Certainly, a real sign of respect for the animal might be to get its name, or kind, right. Of the vile "snuff film" slur, I'd say that's both a term and a product far more likely to be found and appreciated in Aaron Sorkin's Hollywood neck of the woods than in Sarah Palin's. Furthermore, where's Sorkin's appreciation for Palin's environmentalism? She's showing herself to be one of the most advanced of our kind these days: She's a locavore. No carbon footprint on her prime rib.

But what on earth was Sorkin attempting to say with his confused lament that Palin's was the "first moose" ever killed for politics? Palin hunted before politics, and will continue to do so after politics. Same goes for her husband. It's what people do in Alaska -- or Newfoundland. She didn't just take it up for the Discovery Channel. Secondly, unlike those who are on a first-name basis with Martin and Charlie Sheen, most people have considerable admiration for those who can make their way in the wilds. As the Davy Crockett song makes so vividly clear, hunting prowess has always been held in special esteem -- and that esteem was not exhausted with the end of pioneer days. The skill still earns a man -- or a woman -- a singular kind of credit with others.

Sorkin stumbles into this insight but doesn't recognize that he has. How would it advantage Palin to kill a moose or caribou on television unless people saw the deed as something admirable?

I know that back home in Newfoundland, if your local Member of the House of Assembly (MHA) has a moose licence and can find a moose, shoot it, clean it and bring it out -- why then that MHA has shown a kind of credential. He is an adult, a person who can take care of himself, who understands some of the rhythms of Newfoundland life and who is continuing some of its finer traditions. It's a statement. The moose isn't shot for politics, but it inevitably falls into some loosely considered political context. If you're a numb-nut who can't find your way around in the woods and wouldn't know a moose from an oil truck -- why then that's a statement too.

And of course hunting is not just limited to moose: Also pursued for their various delights are (and I'm naming only some examples) partridge, turr, rabbit and, of course, the ubiquitous and savoury seal. Hunting, like poetry, offers both utility and pleasure.

Once again it seems, as is often the case with most matters Palin, that it's the former Alaskan governor's critics who are both out of touch and intemperate.

- Rex Murphy offers commentary weekly on CBC TV's The National, and is host of CBC Radio's Cross Country Checkup.

Read more: http://www.nationalpost.com/todays-paper/What+wrong+with+facing+down+furry+critters/3962233/story.html#ixzz17og74FWg

Thursday, December 9, 2010

Coldest in central England since 1659

Meteorologist Joe Bastardi

8 Dec 10 - "The central England Temperature (CET) from the 1st-7th of December is -1.9, making this the coldest opening week of December since 1879," says meteorologist Joe Bastrardi.

With 1879 being the coldest opening week on CET record, this week has been the second coldest opening week to December since CET records began in 1659.

Those records are for a one-week period.

When you look at the two-week period, says Bastardi, the last week of November and the first week of December, it's the coldest since CET records began in 1659.

This puts central England back to the temperatures of the Little Ice Age.

And there's more to come, Bastardi warns.

"Preparation for renewal of extreme cold from France to Scandinavia and west through the UK should be made."

See entire article:
http://www.accuweather.com/ukie/bastardi-europe-blog.asp?partner=accuweather

The Economic Legacy of the Four-Year Democratic Congress (American Thinker)

 

By Yossi Gestetner

From early 2007 through the end of 2010, the Democrats had strong Majorities in -- and control of -- the US House of Representatives and also the U.S. Senate. Both are chambers where laws and policies that affect the economy are created and shaped.

The following table shows how the Democrat Congress performed on average during its four year tenure, vs. the average of the previous four years, 2003 through the end of 2006, when Republican were at the helm:

Issue/Topic

Democrats

Republicans

Jobs by Year - Average

-1,583,000

+1,672,000

Jobs by Month - Average

-131,916

+139,333

Unemployment Rate - Average

7.48%

5.3%

Budget Deficits - Avrage

$1.143 Trillion

$285 Billion

Dow (DJIA)

0.13% (0.53 Total)

11.04%

S & P 500

1.29%

15.02%

FDIC Bank Closures - Average

79.2

1.75

Following are the numbers in more detail (2010 statistics will need to be adjusted with the close of December. However, the general picture won't change much anyway.):

Non-farm Payroll by Year:

2003 = 87,000;

2004 = 2,047,000

2005 = 2,496,000

2006 = 2,060,000.                   Four Year Total Republicans: 6,690,000 Jobs GAINED.

2007 = 1,078,000

2008 = 3,623,000 Minus

2009 = 4,740,000 Minus

2010 = 951,000                       Four Year Total Democrats: 6,334,000 Jobs LOST!

Take note that the 2009 Stimulus "Could have been worse" year, was indeed worse than the previous year, by 1.1 million more jobs lost.

****

Unemployment Rate by Yearly Average (calculated by dividing in twelve the total monthly Unemployment Rate):

2003  5.99;

2004  5.54;

2005  5.08;

2006  4.61;

2007  4.61;

2008  6.37;

2009  9.28;

2010  9.66

****

Budget Deficits (The Fiscal Years starts three months into the previous colander year, such as FY 2007 was drawn up during 2006 with a Republican Congress). Numbers are in Billions except when indicated otherwise.

FY 2004 = $412

FY 2005 = $318.7

FY 2006 = $247.7

FY 2007 = $162                      Total Added Republican Budget Deficits: $1.140 Trillion.

FY 2008 = $454

FY 2009 = $1.416 Trillion

FY 2010 = $1.294 Trillion

FY 2011 = $1.41 Projected by the White House, July 2010

Total Added Democrats Budget Deficits: $4.574 Trillion!

NOTE: If I hear a Republican say one more time that "we lost our way" on spending, I'll be tempted to jump ff the Tappan Zee Bridge in NY. I'll take a Republican Congress for the next 100 years, four times faster than a Democrat Congress.

                                                       ****

Dow Jones Industrial Average Annual Returns

2003 = 25.32%

2004 = 3.15%

2005 = 0.61% Minus

2006 = 16.29%                                    Total Four Year DJIA Republican Growth: 44.15%

2007 = 6.43%

2008 = 33.84% Minus

2009 = 18.82%

2010 = 9.12% as of the Close Friday 10/3/10.          Total Four Year DJIA Dem Growth: 0.53%

                                                   ****

S&P 500 Index Annual Returns

2003 = 28.72%

2004 = 10.82%

2005 = 4.79%

2006 = 15.74%                                    Total Four Year Republican S&P Growth: 60.07%

2007 = 5.46%

2008 = 37.22%  Minus

2009 = 27.11%

2010 = 9.81% as of the Close Friday December 3, 2010.       Total Four Year Democrat S&P Growth: 5.16%

                                                  ****

FDIC Banks Closures as reported by the FDIC

2003 = 03

2004 = 04

2005 = No Bank Failures

2006 = No Banks Failures                     Total in Four Republican Years: Seven.

2007 = 03

2008 = 25

2009 = 140

2010 = 149 and counting                    Total in Four Democrat Years: 317!

The author can be reached via email yossi@yossigestetner.com

Page Printed from: http://www.americanthinker.com/2010/12/the_economic_legacy_of_the_fou.html at December 09, 2010 - 07:59:20 AM CST

Class Warriors Got What They Wished For (American Thinker)

 

By Randall Hoven
A funny thing happened on the way to spreading the wealth: wealth dried up.

A good class warrior wishes for three things (at least).

  • (1) For tax rates to be highest on the richest. Ideally, only the rich would pay taxes. The Father of Class War, Karl Marx, made "a heavy progressive or graduated income tax" one of the ten planks of his Manifesto.
  • (2) For no one to be super-rich. Ideally, no one would make more than some amount considered too much. Barack Obama, the Son of Class War, once said, "I do think at a certain point you've made enough money."
  • (3) For Government to have plenty of money so that it can spread the wealth and help the needy. The Democratic Party, the Holy Ghost of Class War, put in its 2008 platform, "For families making more than $250,000, we'll ask them to give back a portion of the Bush tax cuts to invest in health care and other key priorities."

Now think about that for a moment.  If the class warriors got their first two wishes, their third wish would be impossible.  If you tax only the rich, yet you have no rich, then government collects no revenue.  You can't spread wealth if there is no wealth.
 
And here is the punch line: that is exactly what is happening now, just not as starkly.
 
In 2007, those making over $200,000 per year did not pay all federal income taxes -- just 52% of them.  Then came the Great Recession.  Taxable income of that group declined 16% from 2007 to 2008.  Taxable incomes went up slightly for the middle class, or those households making between $40,000 and $200,000.
 
And what about the really rich: those with gross incomes over one million dollars?  There were 18% fewer tax returns from such households and 25% less taxable income.  As a result, the federal government collected $60 billion less from such households in 2008 than in 2007.  (See tables at the end of this article.)
 
The Great Recession was a great time for class warriors.  Incomes for the rich went down quite a bit in a single year (and only the first year of the Great Recession) while those for the middle class stayed about the same.
 
The result was predictable: much less revenue for the government.  Federal income taxes from the middle class ($40,000 to $200,000) went up by $2 billion, but those from the rich (over $200,000) went down by $73 billion.  This was not because of tax rate cuts; there weren't any.  It was because there were fewer rich households and less income for such households.
 
Real GDP fell only 2.8% from 2007 to 2008, but federal revenue fell almost twice as much: 5.2% in constant dollars.  Through 2009, federal revenues were down 21% from 2007, leaving a gaping shortfall in revenue of over half a trillion dollars (inflation adjusted) and an unprecedented federal deficit.  (Tax figures for 2009 are not yet available.  I suspect they will show the same pattern: loss of federal revenue due to loss of income at the higher levels.)
 
Revenues did not fall because of a tax rate cut; there was no tax rate cut between 2007 and 2009.  Revenues did not fall because of some give-away to the rich.  In fact, the problem was just the opposite.  Revenues fell because there were fewer rich and the rich made less money -- just as class warriors wanted.
 
We had a progressive tax structure that relied on the rich getting richer.  Then we got what we wished for: for the rich to become like us.  So now we're all broke.  We had a bubble-based tax system, and the bubble burst.
 
Why do you think revenues fell by over 20% to the federal government and states like California during the Great Recession, when GDP fell only 4%?  Because the federal government and states like California have extremely progressive tax structures.  You get rid of the rich, and you get rid of government revenues (and job creation).  Believe it or not, the rich lost more money in the Great Recession than the rest of us did.  Our golden goose is cooked.
 
Discussions of how much to tax the rich are ever more akin to fiddling while Rome is burning.  Before you can get money from the rich, you have to have rich households and they have to have money.  You can't tax what you've destroyed.
 
Be careful what you wish for.  Or vote for.
 
Randall Hoven can be contacted at randall.hoven@gmail.com or via his web site, randallhoven.com.
 
Some key data from the IRS are summarized in the tables below.  Source:  IRS, Table 3.5, for the years 2007 and 2008.  Data for tax year 2009 are not yet available through the IRS site.  (Dollar amounts in the table below are rounded.  Percentage changes were calculated on the unrounded values in the original IRS tables.)
 
Number of Tax Returns

AGI

2007

2008

Change

Under $200,000

105,995,320

103,618,393

-2.2%

$40K to $200K

55,350,570

55,414,032

+0.1%

Over $200,000

4,527,350

4,359,936

-3.7%

Over $1,000,000

391,432

319,432

-18.5%


Taxable Income ($billions)

AGI

2007

2008

Change

Under $200,000

$3,615

$3,592

-0.6%

$40K to $200K

$3,063

$3,067

+0.1%

Over $200,000

$2,449

$2,061

-15.8%

Over $1,000,000

$1,245

$938

-24.6%

 
Federal Personal Income Tax Generated ($billions)

AGI

2007

2008

Change

Under $200,000

$551

$550

-0.2%

$40K to $200K

$486

$488

+0.4%

Over $200,000

$604

$531

-12.0%

Over $1,000,000

$315

$255

-19.1%


Page Printed from: http://www.americanthinker.com/2010/12/class_warriors_got_what_they_w.html at December 09, 2010 - 07:54:45 AM CST

Sunday, December 5, 2010

The last global warming conference ever? (Canada’s Treasure Rex Murphy)

 

Rex Murphy, National Post · Saturday, Dec. 4, 2010

This global-warming/climate-change stuff is a great racket. Over in England right now, they're locked in the jaws of a very early freeze-up. The roads are iced, the plows overworked, and people are angry. But there's a precious subset of the English population that are not enduring the frigid and premature torments of a northern winter. They're the climate-change activists, bureaucrats, politicians, puppeteers and NGOs -- the class of professional alarmists who've been banging on about global warming for close on two decades now. This bunch has exempted itself from the rigors of English November, traded their sackcloth and ashes for sun-wear and tropical breezes.

They're toasting their pasty, righteous, caterwauling epidermi on the golden hot sands of Cancun, Mexico, flopped out amid the bikinis and barbeques while they attempt to spell out a future of rationing and want for all the rest of us. Flown there on taxpayer or foundation money, meeting up with all their buddies from the bust that was Copenhagen, the grim, grey priesthood of "sustainable" living are convening in one of the great sybaritic strips of the entire Western world. The monks are in the cathouse.

But hey, if you're going to do Armageddon -- do it in Cancun. The apocalypse at the all-you-can-eat buffet. Parasailing to Armageddon.

Does not one of the great minds decoding next century's weather see the brain-splitting contradiction of holding a conference warning of the imminent threat of global warming in a venue that mainly exists because people fly there to get warmer? That's right, people spend money to fly to Cancun mainly because it's warmer there than where they live. In essence, Cancun is what the global warming crowd are, otherwise, warning us about.

Perhaps at some level of instinct they do know. Perhaps they know that this show of theirs is on its last legs, the jig is up, the great game is over. After the unsuccessful 2009 Copenhagen conference, they had to have realized that even Al Gore and all Al Gore's grim little men would never be able to put the whole rickety, tendentious machine back together again. After Copenhagen, and especially after Climategate, even the true believers must have lost heart. Witness this year's confabulation. Notice who's not there?

Last year, even the Golden One, Barack Obama, swept dramatically into Denmark. It was the venue for all the A-list politicians. Prime ministers and presidents were everywhere. This year, the world's leaders have stayed away. Even the press, whose Cancun presence is down considerably compared to Copenhagen, smells the decay of a cause.

Some countries have made it clear that they no longer are even pretending to play the global-warming abatement game. "Japan will not inscribe its target under the Kyoto protocol on any conditions or under any circumstances," declared Jun Arima, deputy director-general for environmental affairs at Japan's Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry. Given that his was the country where the Kyoto Protocol was signed, it's a powerful blow to the Gore-ish forces. Perhaps Japan will get one of those cute Fossil of the Day Awards that Canada so excels at collecting.

Could this be the last global warming conference? It's possible. The environmentalists and the activists have had a tin ear and a surplus of righteousness from the beginning. But there's something extravagantly out of key, even for them, in holding their great "Save the Planet" revival at Cancun -- up to now famous for Spring Break and as a hangout for louche Hollywood types and cleavage researchers. It signals they've lost the will to pretend. And with Japan having walked away from the whole idea of Kyoto, it's hard to see how they'll work up the steam for another holiday next year.

- Rex Murphy offers commentary weekly on CBC TV's The National, and is host of CBC Radio's Cross Country Checkup.

Read more: http://www.nationalpost.com/todays-paper/last+global+warming+conference+ever/3927517/story.html#ixzz17F5WQlpo

Saturday, December 4, 2010

Fantasy Figures, Real Pain (American Thinker)

 

By Jeffrey Folks

Early Friday morning, before the Department of Labor released its monthly jobs report, the mainstream media was reporting job gains of as much as 200,000 as more or less the consensus figure. Never mind that 200,000 was not the consensus among reputable economists. The mainstreamers wanted the jobs report to turn up as an assist to the Obama administration, and so they fudged their predictions.

None of those Friday-morning prognosticators will have to face the public again until Monday morning, and by then they will undoubtedly have "forgotten" how far off they were. If they were honest, principled journalists, they would issue a correction at the first opportunity. But that will never happen.

Of course, if mainstream reporters were truly professional, they would never have fudged the figures to begin with. They would never have spent the last two years bending over backwards to make excuses for every misguided policy of the Obama administration. They would never have spent eight years hammering the Bush administration and then indulging in a frenzy of biased reporting with the goal of electing Barack Obama.

By Monday morning, these same newsrooms will undoubtedly have buried the story that the unemployment rate rose in November to 9.8%, well on its way to what reputable economists have long been predicting as a rate above 10% by early 2011. The fact that only 39,000 jobs were created in November is a sobering statistic, especially at a time when the broader unemployment rate stands at 17%.

Just do the math. With 25 million Americans now unemployed or underemployed, it will take 641 months, or 53 years, to create jobs for all who need work. And that figure does not even count the millions of new workers entering the job market each year.

Over and over again, Obama has touted his green jobs initiatives. Just this week, in an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal, the President's EPA Director, Lisa Jackson, insisted that her agency's efforts (that is, to restrict mining, drilling, industrial development, and nearly every other form of growth) will in the long run result in strong job growth. Perhaps Ms. Jackson is thinking about 53 years from now.

Fifty-three years is a long time to wait for a job, but since liberals hope to extend unemployment benefits indefinitely, perhaps 25 million Americans can live on $300 a week until they reach retirement age. Then they can collect Social Security. That's the way it works in Europe, and look at how well it's working out for them.

The real question is, Why are there so few jobs being created? A severe recession like the one we experienced in 2008-2009 is supposed to be followed by a rapid, "V-shaped" recovery. That is what happened following nearly every previous recession. But it is not happening this time. So what's different?

The difference is that Democrats have spent the last two years engaged in an orgy of new spending, regulation, litigation, and taxation -- all of it squarely aimed at America's most successful businesses. Among the thousands of new regulations in the health care reform bill and the Dodd-Frank financial reform legislation is a potentially devastating requirement that retailers report whether their goods contain "conflict metals": gold, tungsten, and the like mined in war-torn Central Africa.

This requirement alone is a potential job-killer of significant proportions. Not only does it require retailers such as Wal-Mart and Best Buy to report information concerning their suppliers that they have no way of obtaining, but it also opens the door to class action lawsuits in connection with most of the electronics and many of the other goods they sell. Perhaps that was Sen. Durbin's intention in sponsoring it.

In any case, the Dodd-Frank conflict metals regulation is just one of thousands of such burdensome requirements with which American companies have been saddled in the past two years. The same regulatory approach -- death by a thousand cuts of regulation and litigation -- has been slapped onto every sector of the economy.

Not even Obama's friends in the media and high tech industries are immune. The Justice Department has opened investigations or filed suit against Intel, Google, and others among Democrat-friendly companies. The same goes for Democratic supporters on Wall Street. Not even their fat campaign contributions can protect them from Obama's hyper-aggressive regulatory czars.

The administration seems to have a particular animus toward oil and gas companies. Not a single deep-water drilling permit has been issued in the six months since the Deepwater Horizon accident, and none seems forthcoming. The entire eastern seaboard and the west coast of Florida have been placed off limits for drilling indefinitely, and this at a time when oil prices are trending upward and pressuring the economy further. The EPA is making a frantic effort to restrict hydraulic fracturing, the most promising source of new domestic supply in a century.

Through all of this, the administration and its boosters in the mainstream media seem clueless. Having subjected every business enterprise to the increased costs of heightened regulation and taxation, liberals wonder why the economy is not creating new jobs. They seem to think that the way to create jobs is to have government take over, impose impossibly onerous regulations, prohibit companies from expanding their operations on environmental grounds, decide what products and services a company can or cannot sell, and then tax whatever profit remains, if any.

If state capitalism of this sort were the way to create jobs, the old Soviet Union would still be around, and North Korea, instead of being the world's most repressive and dangerous dictatorship, would be a shopper's paradise. I don't see too many Fendi stores opening up in Pyongyang anytime soon. Unfortunately, I don't see too many jobs being created anytime soon in Obama's socialist utopia, either.

Jeffrey Folks is author of many books and articles on American culture and politics.

Page Printed from: http://www.americanthinker.com/2010/12/fantasy_figures_real_pain.html at December 04, 2010 - 08:21:52 AM CST

Thursday, December 2, 2010

Top Science Panel Caught in Another Global Warming Data Fraud (Canada Free Press)

 

By John O'Sullivan Wednesday, December 1, 2010

Newly released science book revelation is set to heap further misery on UN global warming researchers. Will latest setback derail Cancun Climate conference?

Authors of a new book ’Slaying the Sky Dragon: Death of the Greenhouse Gas Theory’ claim they have debunked the widely established greenhouse gas theory climate change. In the first of what they say will be a series of sensational statements to promote the launch of their book, they attack a cornerstone belief of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) - what is known as the “carbon isotope argument.”

MiÅ¡o Alkalaj, is one of 24 expert authors of this two-volume publication, among them are qualified climatologists, prominent skeptic scientists and a world leading math professor. It is Alkalaj’s chapter in the second of the two books that exposes the fraud concerning the isotopes 13C/12C found in carbon dioxide (CO2).

If true, the disclosure may possibly derail last-ditch attempts at a binding international treaty to ‘halt man-made global warming.’ At minimum the story will be sure to trigger a fresh scandal for the beleaguered United Nations body.

Do Human Emissions of Carbon Dioxide Exhibit a Distinct Signature?

The low-key internal study focused on the behavior of 13C/12C isotopes within carbon dioxide (CO2) molecules and examined how the isotopes decay over time. Its conclusions became the sole basis of claims that ‘newer’ airborne CO2 exhibits a different and thus distinct ‘human signature.’ The paper was employed by the IPCC to give a green light to researchers to claim they could quantify the amount of human versus natural proportions just from counting the number of isotopes within that ‘greenhouse gas.’

Alkalaj, who is head of Center for Communication Infrastructure at the “J. Stefan” Institute, Slovenia says because of the nature of organic plant decay, that emits CO2, such a mass spectrometry analysis is bogus. Therefore, it is argues, IPCC researchers are either grossly incompetent or corrupt because it is impossible to detect whether carbon dioxide (CO2) in the atmosphere is of human or organic origin.

Skeptics Out to Derail Cancun Climate Conference?

Cynics are already claiming ‘Isotope-gate’ is more than just a promotional stunt to hype this book launch. They say its also deliberately timed to disrupt the latest major international climate conference in Cancun, Mexico (November 29th - December 10th).

The Cancun Climate conference (COP 16) is seen as a make or break attempt by world leaders to secure a binding international treaty to limit emissions of carbon dioxide after the failure of the Copenhagen Climate Summit last year. Copenhagen was undermined by the Climategate revelations and this latest attempt by skeptics may be a repeat.

The ‘Isotope-gate’ story is one of many planned promotional releases from the book and this publication is bound to cause embarrassment to delegates in Mexico if the revelations it contains become widely known.

Worryingly for Cancun (and the IPCC) this new book makes far bolder claims than have been made before by skeptics. Its authors say they have scientifically and mathematically disproved the greenhouse gas theory. The theory is the bedrock of all scientific claims that humans are responsible for climate change.

‘Slayers’ Book Reveals New Evidence of UN Climate Fraud

The 13C/12C argument being attacked by MiÅ¡o Alkalaj may be found in IPCC’s AR4—The Physical Science Basis Working Group. The IPCC clarifies its position on Page 139 of that chapter.

According to MiÅ¡o the fatal assumption made by the IPCC is that the atmospheric concentration of the 13C isotope (distinctive in prehistoric plants) are fixed. They also assume C3-type plants no longer exist so would need to be factored into the equations. Indeed, as MiÅ¡o points out such plants, “make up 95% of the mass of all current plant life.”

Therefore, decay of 95% of present-day plant material is constantly emitting the 13C-deficient carbon dioxide supposedly characteristic of coal combustion—and CO2 emitted by plant decay is an order of magnitude greater than all human-generated emissions.

‘Isotope-gate’ is Twin Brother of Himalayagate

But a more sinister twist to the story is not just that the researchers erred in mistakenly overlooking the flaws about the 13C isotope, but that they never referred the analysis to outsider verification.

As with the Himalayagate controversy, the Prentice paper was never reviewed beyond the secretive four walls of UN climate alarmism; it relied entirely on an internal uncorroborated source.

On this cynical practice MiÅ¡o observes, “Few readers will be bothered to follow the trail all the way and especially not the ‘policymakers.’ But the few that do frequently find out that the argument is circular (A quotes B and B quotes A), etc.”

Thus, there exists no proof of any such distinct ‘human signal’ anywhere in samples of atmospheric CO2 and the IPCC is discredited. Therefore, once again, the public has been shown compelling evidence of how it was duped by junk science promoted knowingly by an international gang of fraudsters.

References:

IPCC (TAR) Third Report (2001), ‘The Scientific Basis,’ Working Group 1

IPCC (FAR) Fourth Report (2007) ‘The Physical Science Basis,’ Working Group 1

Ball, T., Johnson, C., Hertzberg, M., Olson, J.A., et al., ’Slaying the Sky Dragon: Death of the Greenhouse Gas Theory,’ (November, 2010), accessed online at: amazon.com (November 26, 2010).

Wednesday, December 1, 2010

How to Recognize a Skunk Or Why Most Americans Can't Think -- But You Can

By Aaron Zelman and Claire Wolfe

"Pretty kitty!" cries the toddler -- as he reaches to pet the fluffy black critter with the white stripes that's wandered into the yard.

Pffffft! Some kitty!

Experience teaches its lessons vividly. But when it comes to evaluating information that we have no personal experience with, even many educated adults can't tell the kitty (truth) from the skunk (propaganda and disinformation).

Has this ever happened to you?

Reading the morning paper, you come across a wire-service article on a subject you know well -- guns. The article is filled with biased language ("gun violence," "spraying bullets" "million moms") and statistics that are either made up or cooked from highly unscientific methodology ("12 students killed by guns every day," "43 times more likely to be killed by a gun in your own home"). You grumble about media bias, then turn the page.

There you read an article from the same wire service. But this one is on a subject you have no particular knowledge of. "World Population Headed for 10 Billion by 2010." "Unemployment Reaches New High of 9.3 Percent." "Study Shows Women's Risk of Heart Disease as High as Men's." "Polar Ice Caps Shrinking," "Income Gap Increases between Blacks and Whites," "New Vaccine is Safe, Says CDC."

And you believe it. Because you have no specific reason NOT to. You may even pass the latest newsbit to co-workers at the proverbial water cooler. Or worse, you base votes, daily anxieties, political contributions, and donations to charity on what you've learned. Your children hear similar information on TV and they believe it. They go to school, where their teachers treat such news stories as fact. The entire culture is steeped every day in "news" whose credibility relies entirely on our blind faith.

Yet every other news item may be as untrustworthy as that anti-gun editorial that masqueraded as "news."

How do we tell truth from fiction, or recognize when half-truths and twisted language are being used to manipulate us, without spending our lives tracking down every obscure databit or factoid behind every news story?

We can't. Not 100 percent -- though we'll describe some easy ways to recognize those propaganda skunks when we see them.

But first, how did things get this way?

"The science of ruling"

It all began with Sigmund Freud.

More precisely, it began with Edward L. Bernays, Freud's American nephew and disciple. In the early 20th Century, Bernays took the crude, razz-ma-tazz occupation of press agentry, added psychological manipulation, laid it all on top of some of the most shocking elitism imaginable -- and created a little-understood but all-pervasive pseudoscience: public relations.

Here's what Bernays believed about people like you and me:

  • That we are driven by "the passions of the pack in ... mob violence and the passions of the herd in ... panic."
  • That we have "logic-proof compartments" in our minds that "prevent [us] from seeing in terms of experience and thought rather than in terms of group reaction."
  • And that we are "remarkably susceptible to leadership."

These weren't just casual observations. An interviewer who spoke with Bernays late in his long life was struck by the way he repeated and repeated his distrust of ordinary people, and his belief that we not only don't think, but can't think.

Bernays believed that he and other members of the elite were exactly the leaders we needed to save us from our primitive, animal-like selves -- and to save orderly society from us.

"If we understand the mechanism and motives of the group mind," he wrote, the elite could "control and regiment the masses according to our will without them knowing it ... just as the motorist can regulate the speed of his car by manipulating the flow of gasoline." He further said, "The duty of the higher strata of society -- the cultivated, the learned, the expert, the intellectual -- is therefore clear. They must inject moral and spiritual motives into public opinion."

Inject their idea of "moral" and "spiritual," that is. And they weren't merely using metaphors. Bernays and the intellectual, governmental elite for whom he practiced his new "science" literally believed that they must "creat[e] man-made gods ... who assert subtle social control" to "bring order out of chaos."

Of course, another word for "chaos" is freedom -- the millions of free choices made by individuals.

What Bernays and his followers aimed for instead was a kind of hive-like cooperation. Their task: to persuade us to see the world exactly as they wish us to see it -- so that we would then live as they wish us to live, buy what they wish us to buy, believe what they wish us to believe, fear what they wish us to fear, and hate whom they wish us to hate.

Foundations, "experts" and mass manipulation

The first thing Bernays did was to start establishing "... more institutes, funds, institutions, and foundations than Rockefeller, Carnegie, and Filene together."

Why? Because if it's necessary to "scientifically" manage our "group mind," then who better do it than certified "experts" and sages -- people we are predisposed to trust without question?

Bernays' institutes, however, were designed to produce whatever statistics or pronouncements Bernays and his clients wished.

For instance, Bernays neglected to tell the public that his Temperature Research Foundation, whose goal was "to disseminate impartial, scientific information concerning the latest developments in temperature control as they affect the health, leisure, happiness, and economy of the American people" was actually funded by the nice folks selling Kelvinator refrigerators.

That pattern has continued to this day -- with thousands of (tax-exempt!) research foundations aggressively promoting everything from genetically engineered foods (with funding from Montsanto, DuPont, and Coca Cola) to citizen disarmament, and with charitable foundations provoking anxiety over an endless stream of new, "scientifically proven" problems.

Governments, war, and catastrophe

Using dubious studies and well-paid "experts" to sell products or politics is, sadly, not the worst of Bernays' legacy as the founder of modern public relations.

It was Bernays who, working for the U.S. government, helped whip Americans into World War I by propagating the mantra "Make the world safe for democracy."

Just as Bernays was Freud's disciple, Bernays himself had disciples. Here's one you'll recognize: Joseph Goebbels. Hitler's propaganda chief used Bernays' book Crystalizing Public Opinion as the basis of his campaign to prepare Germany for the destruction of the Jews.

Shortly after the conclusion of the Persian Gulf War, it came out that that many of the most terrible claims made about Saddam Hussein and Iraq had been issued by the giant PR firm, Hill & Knowlton. And who was its client? The government of Kuwait. Some claims were true, some doubtful. But true or false, Americans were shamefully manipulated into war frenzy by covert, highly paid agents of a foreign government.

(Pretty ironic that the very elitists who sought to save us from our allegedly savage natures have spent so much effort coaxing us into war and destruction.)

Most of the daily PR that masquerades as news doesn't produce such calamities. Nevertheless, its overall impact is dangerous. It helps destroy both independent thought and freedom. It helps transfer money and power from individuals to giant institutions.

Are we saying that every journalist working today is consciously lying with the goal of controlling us? No. But from journalism school onward, reporters are steeped in the premises of control -- the belief that the duty of the communications elite is not to find out the truth and convey information, but to mold the masses.

Even when they don't set out to deceive us, reporters often propagate false or misleading information. Because of time pressures, budget limitations, demands from their bosses, personal biases, and sometimes through sheer laziness, reporters often simply pass along "news" provided to them by corporations, foundations, political organizations, and government agencies. They may trim it, rearrange it, reword it a bit, and add an interview to it. But one thing they rarely do is seriously investigate the reliability of information that's handed to them.

And every one of those institutions producing those news releases and white papers has an agenda. They want your tax money, your submissiveness, your contributions, your faith, your purchases, your unquestioning belief in their causes, and ultimately they want to control what you believe, how you live, and what you think.

Or what you think you think.

Don't get skunked

Here are nine simple tips to avoid getting skunked by biased news.

1. If you see a statistic, doubt it.

"Three million Americans homeless," "12 students killed by gun violence every day." "Average home price rises."

Unless you've personally reviewed the data and the methodology, assume all statistics are untrustworthy. In the three examples given here, the one about homelessness was simply made up by political activist Mitch Snyder and repeated for years by irresponsible journalists. The claim about dead students rests on several bizarre assumptions: first, that anyone under 24 is a "child," then that all "children" are "students," then there's a dollop of sheer imagination added on top of that. The one about "average" home prices ... well, if you understand the differences between "means," "medians," "averages," and "modes," you can come up with almost any "average" house price you want, depending on whether your aim is to puff up the status of a community or lower its property taxes.

2. Just because a claim comes from an "expert" doesn't make it true.

Remember that every foundation or institute, even the most famous, has an agenda. The most eminent scientists can be bought. Even the most renowned "expert" can be just plain flat wrong. Dr. Arthur Kellermann (he of the "43 times more likely to die" claim) and the gently named "Americans for Gun Safety" aren't trustworthy just because they sound unbiased or authoritative. And celebrities -- even the ones on your side -- don't possess any magical connection to the truth.

3. Just because something happened after doesn't mean it happened because of something else.

When you hear a statement like, "Poverty decreased after the Johnson's Great Society programs went into effect," it sounds plausible to assume the programs caused the drop. But never assume a cause and effect relationship unless you can actually demonstrate one. (In fact, in this case, the connection is unprovable and the statement is downright false. Poverty rates had been plummeting before those programs took effect. They flattened out soon afterward and have remained nearly static for more than 30 years as the programs have grown bigger and more plentiful.) Unless you establish cause and effect, then it's just as logical to assume that Al Gore lost the presidential election because Elvis was sighted at Burger King in 1978, or that Hillary Clinton was elected to the Senate because Monica Lewinsky gained 90 pounds.

4. Watch for biased language.

Biased language comes in many flavors. Gun owners may be most familiar with the kind that's used against us (like the politically concocted term "assault weapon," or "gun violence," which makes it sound as if Glocks and Rugers are prowling the streets on their own, stalking victims). But examine the language of any news article. Look for terms designed to evoke automatic agreement or automatic distaste, rather than convey information: "sensible," "common-sense," "Frankenfoods," "mean-spirited," "slash," "moms," "urgent," "needy," "reasonable," "for the children," "sacred," "greedy," "homeland" -- the list is endless.

And yes, you'll catch us using biased words in this article. Emotional words, judgmental words, angry words, stirring words belong in writing that's designed to inspire, outrage, or otherwise move us. But when you see emotion-evoking words in the so-called news, beware.

5. Question conventional wisdom.

If "everyone knows" something -- but the truth can't be independently verified, then perhaps you should be the one who questions what "everybody knows."

One thing "everybody knows," thanks to incessant propaganda and misleading statistics, is that guns are more likely to endanger their owners and owners' children than to prevent crime. This isn't true, but the myth has prevented many women (the very people who most need the equalizing protection of firearms) from learning to use guns and effectively protecting their families. How many have become victims as a result of this single bit of propaganda?

Remember, "everybody" once knew you could "scientifically" detect a person's character by feeling the bumps on his head. "Everybody" once knew women shouldn't be educated because all that brainwork would draw energy away from their reproductive organs. "Everybody" once knew the earth was flat. It's remarkable how often "everybody" gets it wrong.

6. If the news makes you feel fear or anxiety, take a deep breath and give yourself a reality check.

Do you think it's only a matter of time until the oceans are dead and devoid of living creatures? Do you fear that criminals lurk on every street corner? Do you worry that the world will soon collapse in a chaos of starvation? Do you believe America is suffering from a plague of mental illness, desperately requiring treatment?

Sometimes there's genuine reason to feel anxiety about the news. There certainly was on September 11, 2001. There certainly is if a serial killer s loose in your neighborhood. But most of the time, when we read "scientific" or sociological "news" reports on "rising tide of gun violence," "threat to the global environment," or "new health threat to our children," we need to ask: Who benefits? As often as not, news stories reporting nebulous threats to our well being are created to help some non-profit group get more funding, help political interests drum up knee-jerk support for new laws ("We must DO SOMETHING about ...!"), or persuade you to buy something. (Isn't it funny how all those news stories about rising depression rates and childhood mental illness match up so well with the rising tide of drug-makers' feelgood ads on TV?)

7. Anybody claiming to be "just plain folks" probably isn't.

When 40,000 "gun-control" advocates showed up in Washington calling themselves the "Million Mom March," they weren't merely using biased (and inaccurate) language. They were trying to give a grassroots appearance to an effort driven by millions of dollars in foundation funding and deep political connections. (The media forgot to tell us that the "ordinary housewife" who organized the group was a former press secretary for Dan Rather who also had family connections to the Clintons.)

Similar tricks are used by corporations, who like to put ordinary employees' faces in ads and news stories as a means of saying, "We're not a multi-billion dollar, soulless, inter-global conglomerate; we're 'just folks.' Just like you." Don't believe it unless you know it for sure. Particularly don't believe any political movement is "grassroots" if the approach is slick or if the alleged "grassroots" group comes out of nowhere with big money and big media connections.

8. Don't accept dehumanizing of opponents.

In some ways, dehumanizing opponents is the most obvious of all forms of bias in the news. It's also the cruelest because, by setting opponents up as non-humans, it can lay the groundwork for the annihilation of a minority group or the destruction of liberty. The classic example is Hitler and Goebbels using propaganda to persuade Germans that Jews were nothing but "vermin" or "cancer." Yet we tend not to notice dehumanization unless we sympathize with the maligned group. We know that when government agents and the media use terms like "extremist," "religious fanatic," "gun nut," or "hate group," they're justifying injustice against unpopular people. Yet we may not object to epithets like "left-wing lunatic," "pinko," or "bomb-throwing anarchist." Or "right-wing Islamic fundamentalist." It's a matter of whose ox is being gored. Nevertheless, when you see any dehumanizing, demonizing epithets in the "news," no matter who the target, it's once again time to beware.

9. Polls tell us more about pollsters than about reality.

A friend of ours was once asked to participate in a survey to "determine [her] risk of being a victim of 'gun violence.'" One of the risk factors was, "Have you ever heard gunfire near your home?" Asked in downtown Washington, DC, that question might actually assess a risk. But our friend -- who lives in the woods between a shooting range and a quarry where kids plink at soda cans -- just burst into laughter.

This is one of many problems with polls. They try to squeeze a complex reality into a soundbite (and often do it in a biased way, besides). Ask a thousand people, "Do you favor reasonable gun control?" and an overwhelming majority invariably says, "Yes!" The media trumpets the figure. But get specific and it's a different story: "Would you favor Senator Shoehorn's gun registration plan if the cost were $700 million or higher?" "Do you believe members of your household would be safer if the law required you to lock your guns away where you couldn't reach them quickly?" Suddenly, public support for "reasonable gun control" plummets.

With the exception of a very few well-designed, unbiased polls, all polls are essentially meaningless. Their value lies in PR.

These tips should get you started. If you're interested in learning more about the skunks in the media works and how to protect against them, try some of these books and Web sites:

Read all about it

Quotes and some information in our article came from

Trust Us, We're Experts! by Sheldon Rampton and John Stauber (Jeremy P. Tarcher/Putnam, 2001) (Ironically, this book uses many of the same propaganda tools it criticizes.) [Buy from Amazon.com: Paperback or Hardback ]

and Father of Spin: Edward L. Bernays and the Birth of Public Relations by Larry Tye (Owl Books, 2002). [Buy from Amazon.com: Paperback or Hardback ]

Other great resources on PR and propaganda include

How to Lie with Statistics by Darrell Huff (W.W. Norton & Co., 1954) [Buy from Amazon.com: Paperback ]

"Disarming the Data Doctors: How to Debunk the 'Public Health' Basis for 'Gun Control'" by Richard W. Stevens. On the JPFO Web site at http://www.jpfo.org/doctors-epidemic.htm

Junk Science Web Page http://www.junkscience.com/

The Nizkor Project. Plain-language explanations of 42 common logical fallacies http://www.nizkor.org/features/fallacies/

To debunk the myths of government and 'gun control' read:

The State vs the People: The Rise of the American Police State by Claire Wolfe and Aaron Zelman (Mazel Freedom Press, 2002) [Buy from JPFO ]

Death by Gun Control: The Human Cost of Victim Disarmament by Richard W. Stevens and Aaron Zelman (Mazel Freedom Press, 2001) [Buy from JPFO ]

Dial 911 and Die by Richard W. Stevens (Mazel Freedom Press, 1999) [Buy from JPFO ]

The Seven Myths of Gun Control by Richard Poe (Prima Publishing, 2001) [Buy from Amazon.com: Hardback ]

Join JPFO America's Most Aggressive Defender of Firearms Ownership

Tuesday, November 30, 2010

EPA Fraud: Chevy Volt, Nissan Leaf Actually Get Only 23, 25 MPG (PAGING DR SUZUKI–comments?)

 

The MPG figure must be calculated where the energy is produced. Doesn't matter if that happens in the car's engine ... or in the coal plant, as with the Leaf and Volt.

November 30, 2010 - by Chris J Kobus

 

You may have heard the mileage rating for the Nissan Leaf is 99 MPG (miles per gallon equivalent). Here’s what the sticker looks like (I highlighted the relevant portions that I will expand upon):

As Auto Blog says of the rating: “It looks good.” Of course it looks good. But there’s a whole lot more to the story. Note that the MPG rating is MPG equivalent. The MSM has been dropping the “equivalent,” making it seem to consumers that the vehicle is far more efficient than it truly is. Which is the intent, of course.

The ratings for the Chevy Volt have just been released as well. From the Detroit Free Press:

Chevy Volt to hit 93 m.p.g. in electric-only mode; battery-only Nissan Leaf to reach 99 m.p.g.

There is not a single instance of the word “equivalent” in the entire article. Nor is there any mention of last year’s claim that the Volt gets 230 miles per gallon (that was a different fraudulent number, based on a separate fraudulent scheme).

The current “miles per gallon equivalent” is a fraud perpetrated to hide the true environmental cost of these cars. One gallon of gas does have about 33.5 kilowatt-hours of chemical potential (depending on blend, additives, etc). And about that much energy is needed to get the Leaf to go 99 miles, and the Volt to go 93. But here’s where the fraud is perpetrated: the electricity for those vehicles is being generated by mostly coal power plants that are only about 33% efficient (minus transmission losses and losses from charging). Coal plants are off-site power generators (whereas car engines are on-board) and are totally ignored in the EPA rating.

Let me illustrate by example how this scheme works, and why it’s such a fraud.

Let’s say you took your gas-guzzling engine out of your car and hooked it up to a generator in your garage. The engine has a fuel efficiency of 15 MPG. That’s roughly 25% efficient (a 300 HP engine burns about 1000 HP of gas). You run the engine to generate electricity (let’s assume, just for kicks, that the generator hooked up to your car engine is 100% efficient) to charge your Nissan Leaf or Chevy Volt. Guess what the mileage of that Leaf is? The EPA says you will still get 99 MPG overall. But you actually used four gallons, not one, to get that far, thanks to the charging engine’s 25% efficiency.

The real efficiency of the Leaf is dependent on the efficiency of the coal power plant: the Leaf gets 25 MPG, not 99. The Chevy Volt gets 23 MPG, not 93.

The EPA is purposely comparing apples to oranges, conveniently hiding the fact that you are simply displacing gasoline usage with coal. The fact that you don’t have to directly throw coal into your car doesn’t mean you aren’t using any. Indeed, the overall efficiency of electric vehicles charged on coal is no better than a car with a spark ignition engine.

And far short of the efficiencies achieved with diesel.

Just in case anyone out there is opining that we should therefore go with “renewable sources” (wind, solar etc.), that will make the available energy problem even worse.

Nature will always get its pound of flesh, and the EPA’s intentional misleading of consumers doesn’t change the fact that we will be no less dependent on fossil fuel at all — and may be more so in this case. As it is, without far more nuclear power plants, the combination of using coal with lithium — the mining of which is one of the dirtiest operations known to man — may well be environmentally worse than just burning gasoline, and is definitely worse than burning diesel.

The Obama administration should hand out a blue pill with each purchase of the Chevy Volt, so you can smugly drive around in ignorant bliss.

Chris Kobus is an Associate Professor in the Department of Mechanical Engineering at Oakland University where he has worked since receiving his Ph.D. in 1998. He is the Director of the Clean Energy Research Center (CERC), and his research focus is in the broad field of energy transport and conversion.

The Economic Reality of the California Budget Crisis

The population of Ontario is one fifth  of California’s.  It has the same gross deficit.  However bad California is, multiply it by 5.  Why isn’t Hudak SCREAMING? 

 

 

California is a very large room, and perhaps that is why the state’s political machine has so long been able to ignore the multi-billion dollar elephant that is the state budget shortfall. But there comes a point where the size of the room is irrelevant. Where evasion is not only impermissible, but impossible. Where the only alternatives are fundamentally reworking long-standing policies—and being crushed under the weight of the beast. The current budget crisis is proof that California has reached that point.

California’s financial situation is dire. According to the Legislative Analyst Office (LAO), the state faces a $20.7 billion deficit for the 2010-2011 fiscal year. Even the Governor’s Office, which uses more optimistic projections, places that figure $18.9 billion. Recall that the Governor’s Office predicted a $500 million reserve for 2009-2010, while the actual year-end figure was a deficit of $6.6 billion. And the $20 billion deficit for 2010-2011 still masks the actual size of California’s spending issues. Much of the governor’s deficit reduction efforts—approximately 40%— focus not on reducing state spending, but on “aggressively seek[ing] additional federal funding,” with a projected total of $8 billion of California’s spending financed by uncertain, one-time federal relief.

It would be one thing if California had reached this point because low revenues were insufficient to finance necessary spending obligations. But it is quite another when the state has seen revenues increase 30% since 2000, and still managed to bring multi-billion dollar deficits upon itself by expanding its expenditures 17% more.

Figure 1: Expenditure Growth outpaces Revenue Growth:

Expenditure vs. Revenue Growth

There can be no contention that the discrepancy is the consequence of California’s reluctance to tax its citizens. Indeed, the state has long had to maintain some of the of the highest tax rates in the nation to bear the cost of this spending growth. Compared to other states, California has the highest sales tax rate, the second highest top income tax rate, and one of the highest corporate tax rates which translate into the sixth highest per capita collections from corporate income taxes. California’s per capita state tax revenue as a percentage of personal income stood at 6.3% for 2009, well above the national median of 5.8%, and the state had the 12th highest per capita tax burden. Nonetheless, California last year also had the third highest budget deficit as a percentage of its overall budget.

Nor can the spending gap be explained by population growth or inflation. Since 1990, per capita spending has increased over 87%; inflation, as measured by the California Consumer Price Index, rose only 66%.

Figure 2: Per Capita Spending Growth Outpaces Inflation:

Per Capita Spending Growth vs. Inflation

Looking at the operation of the state reveals, all too clearly, that the actual driver of the state budget deficit is inefficiency—systematic, structural, politically sanctioned inefficiency. Per person, California’s spending is the twelfth highest in the nation. Lest anyone claim this is inevitable because of its size, note that California’s per capita spending is 68% higher than that of Texas, the next largest state by population, and 21% higher than the average for the ten largest states by population.

Figure 3: Comparing California’s Per Capita Spending:

Per Capita Spending Comparisons

Much of the reason the state government is so costly to operate is the number of employees it hires and the amount it pays them. From 1990 to 2009, the number of state employees rose approximately 37% percent; the number of state employees per capita, approximately 7%. And some of these employees are among of the highest-paid state workers in the nation. California public school teachers and prison guards, for instance, earn more than their counterparts in any other state, and over $10,000 and $20,000 per year, respectively, more than the national average. At the same time, the state pension system has resulted in $100 billion in unfunded retirement liabilities for state employees, which, the LAO notes, “because of recent investment value declines for retirement systems, may actually exceed $130 billion.”

Figure 4: Rise in the Number of State Employees:

Growth in Number of State Employees

Governor Schwarzenegger has attempted to attribute, at least in part, the state budget gap to the fall in revenues as a consequence of the 2008-2009 recession. But the recession merely laid bare fiscal instability that had been mounting for the past 20 years. The state budget has long been alternating between precarious, short-lived balance and deep, systematic deficits, particularly in the past decade. Looking to projections by the LAO, we see that even during periods of strong economic growth from 2005 to 2007, the state continued to post multibillion dollar operating deficits leading up to the 2008-2009 recession. And, in large part, the only reason the state was able to finance those deficits was through borrowing backing by expectations that housing prices would maintain their steep upward trajectory, since the growth of the housing market was a major source of revenue for the state. Given that the state faced operating deficits while the housing bubble was nearing its peak, it is no surprise that California finds itself with a projected $20 billion deficit for the 2010-2011 fiscal year with the bubble burst and the ramification ongoing.

And those ramifications place significant weight on the state’s fiscal standing, and, in turn, its basic operations. In July of 2009, the LAO released an open letter to a member of the Assembly detailing California’s liabilities, which are not included in the budget deficit calculations. These liabilities totaled over $200 billion, with $63.9 billion consisting of short- to mid-term debt. Around $35 billion of that is the direct result of deferrals and loans the state has used to close past budget gaps. As a reflection as the magnitude of these liabilities, California’s bond rating has fallen sharply in the past decade, leaving it with the lowest rating of any state. This not only makes it more difficult for the state to bring in short-term revenue by issuing bonds, but also increases the long-term interest costs California will have to pay on the bonds it does manage to issue.

But the gravity of the state’s present fiscal distress will be an afterthought if current spending policies remain in place. LAO projections place the annual operating deficit for each of the next five fiscal years near $20 billion.

Figure 5: Projected Operating Deficits under Standing Law:

Projected Operating Deficits

Such deficits are not merely unsustainable—they are unendurable. Given that its liabilities are already massive, California would have no choice but to file for bankruptcy if these projections are fulfilled. We have already begun to see the consequences of forced, unplanned spending cuts. Consider the UC system, for which tuition has risen 32% while its course offerings and student services have been sharply reduced and staff cuts sharply increased. These types of emergency retrenchments, made more severe, and imposed across all state institutions—that is the reality these figures project. And that is the reality California is on course to encounter.

Avoiding that reality demands a diametric change in state spending policy. Such a change, in turn, demands that the voters and political leaders of California come to grasp and apply the basic economic principles which have so long been absent from California’s budgeting decisions. The foremost of these is that state spending is consumption. Every dollar the state spends represents real wealth used, exhausted, depleted. The more the state spends, the more it consumes; but the amount of wealth available for consumption is finite and limited. No number of payments deferred, loans taken out, or shifts from one fund to another, will allow the state to consume more than it brings in, which means, to consume at its present rate.

The implication of this principle is that California’s spending structure must be made efficient. The state cannot afford to continue to pay for any program that chances to find political favor. It must prioritize. We have reached the point where something must be cut—indeed, not just something, but much. And what is maintained, needs to be reformed to function more cost-effectively. California currently has positions, sub-groups, and entire departments charged with the same purpose; eliminating redundancy and streamlining the state government has the potential to reduce spending by billions of dollars. That reduction will require cutting the number, pay, and benefits of state workers. It might be pleasant to entertain the idea of fixing the budget gap without doing so, but the idea clashes with the economic reality that state employees’ pay is a core reason for California’s operating deficits.

These suggestions are common sense. Here, though, applying common sense requires grappling with a complex, large-scale problem. And that is what California’s political leaders have shown themselves unwilling, or perhaps unable, to do. They will ignore the elephant at the peril of the state. If California’s political system is to confront spending excesses and inefficiencies, it is the voters of California who will have to not only point out that elephant, but force their elected officials to take action before what fiscal standing California has left is trampled as well. It is our money that is being consumed. It is our state government that is financially unstable. And it is our responsibility to bring common sense to bear on a budgeting process in which it is precisely sense that has been lacking.